Book Review: A Court of Thorns and Roses

Today’s review is on A Court of Thorns and Roses by Sarah J. Maas

I have been wanting to read this book since I heard about it a year ago and I finally got a chance to when one of the groups I belong to on Goodreads decided to read it this month. I really enjoyed this book, if you enjoyed Throne of Glass you will enjoy this book. There are a few steamy scenes in this book, but besides that it was really good.

Once again Sarah J. Maas builds another awesome world without the descriptions being too cumbersome. It is a retelling of three fairy-tales/folk tales: Beauty and the Beast; Tamlin (which is a Scottish ballad, I think); and East f the Sun, West of the Moon. It takes place in a world where both fae and humans live, except they live in different areas and the humans hate the fae. The main character Feyre kills a wolf, which happened to be one of the fae and as a result she has to go live among them as punishment. However, she soon discovers that not everything that she was told about the faerie world is necessarily true, as she lives in the house of one of the High Fae, Tamlin.

As I mentioned before, the world-building in this book is great, and I also appreciate how there is a map of this world at the beginning of the novel so that readers can see the various places where the novel takes place.

So much happens in this book, however it does start off kind of slow. The plot takes so many twists and turns I wasn’t expecting, especially in the last 150-200 pages which was really unexpected. There is of course romance, however it isn’t really insta-love, which is common in most books. The romance develops over the course of most of the novel. I cannot say anything more about it because otherwise it might spoil some other plot points.

The characters were really enjoyable, except Rhysand, who is introduced later on in the novel, and of course the other villains. I enjoyed seeing how Feyre develops throughout the novel, especially in her relationship with her family and her relationship with Tamlin. Lucian was also a pretty cool character, even though he came across as a jerk most of the time, it was still enjoyable to his development as a character.

I really need to read A Court of Mist and Fury (the sequel), but I don’t know if I could wait a whole year for the third book to come out if I really like it. But I am planning on reading it soon-ish.

I am giving this book 4/5 Stars because there was great world-building and character development and I didn’t want it to end. However, the several steamy scenes made me feel a bit uncomfortable and didn’t really seem necessary.

Happy Reading,
Janelle L. C.

P.S. If you have any book recommendations, let me know and I will check them out 🙂 

Blog Tour and Giveaway: A Lady Unrivaled

Click here to purchase your own copy.

About the Book

Amid the Unforgettable Cotswolds, the Final Grasp for the Fire Eyes Diamonds Could Threaten Them All

Lady Ella Myerston can always find a reason to smile–even if it’s just in hope that tomorrow will be better than today. All her life everyone has tried to protect her from the realities of the world, but Ella knows very well how the dangerous Fire Eyes diamonds have haunted her brother and their friends, and she won’t wait for it to strike again. She intends to take action . . . and if that happens to involve an adventurous trip to the Cotswolds, then so much the better.

Lord James Cayton has already broken two hearts, including that of his first wife, who died before he could convince himself to love her. Now he’s determined to live a better life . . . but that proves complicated when old acquaintances pull Cayton into their desperate attempt to seize the jewels. He does his best to remove the intriguing Lady Ella from danger, but the stubborn girl won’t budge. How else can he redeem himself, though, but by saving her–and his daughter–from those intent to destroy them all?

My Thoughts

I really enjoyed this book, it was interesting to read a book set during the Edwardian era – I haven’t read a whole lot set during this time period. This is also the first Roseanna White book that I have read and I think it was a great introduction to the author. 
I really enjoyed the mystery and the intrigue surrounding the “Fire Eyes” diamonds, I was left guessing as to what would happen regarding all the drama that seems to follow those who have been impacted to some extent by the diamonds and how different people react differently. 
The characters were well developed and I really liked Lady Ella because she was so spunky and was constantly trying to prove that she could be an independent woman. I also enjoyed seeing her interaction with the other characters in the novel. I liked that she was realistic in some of the thoughts and “struggles” that she endures over the course of the novel. I also enjoyed Lord Cayton, although I felt like he was constantly focused on what he had done in his past – especially since he was continuously reminded of it – and it was frustrating. 
Even though this novel is the last one in the series, it can be read as a stand-alone. I really enjoyed the ploy, although sometimes it did tend to drag a little bit. 
I am giving this book 4/5 Stars because I enjoyed it, although some of the characters did get on my nerves and there were some slow parts in the plot. 

About the Author

Roseanna M. White pens her novels beneath her Betsy Ross flag, with her Jane Austen action figure watching over her. When not writing fiction, she’s homeschooling her two children, editing and designing, and pretending her house will clean itself. Roseanna is the author of a slew of historical novels and novellas, ranging from biblical fiction to American-set romances to Edwardian British romances. She makes her home in the breathtaking mountains of West Virginia. You can learn more about her and her stories at

Guest Post from Roseanna White

So Very Ella

Back in 2008, I went to my first writers conference, where I met my current best friend and critique partner. I’d been pitching the first book in a series I was rewriting from my childhood, so this was the first project of mine our newly formed critique group did together. Specifically, the third book in the series, which I was then calling Diamond Blaze.

It was about a girl very much like me. Optimistic in the extreme. Always looking for a reason to smile. Her name was Lady Ella Myerston, and though she was the heroine in the third novel in a series—friend to heroine from book 1 and sister of hero in book 2—Ella stood on her own. Or I hoped she did. You see, it’s not very often I try to write a character so much like me, and I wasn’t sure what my new critique partners would think.

I was delighted and relieved when my critters, as I call them, loved her—it felt a little like them loving me. 😉 With Stephanie, that BFF/critique partner, Ella became part of our language. “That’s so Ella” meant “that’s so hopefully and optimistic.” It’s a phrase we used for years, long after that series got shelved and we focused on other projects.

When I finally sold a rewrite of the first book to Bethany House and The Lost Heiress released last September, I was so excited to get to breathe new life into the other books in the series as well. I gave some new twists and turns to Brice’s and Rowena’s story in The Reluctant Duchess, took it to new depths, but it was still largely the story I’d first written seven years before.

Ella’s story, though . . . we eventually settled on the title A Lady Unrivaled, but it was the hardest one in the series for us to name. And writing! Ella’s story didn’t work anymore as I’d had it. I had to toss out the entire thing and start fresh, with a new premise and new plot. But Ella—Ella had to remain Ella. I learned more about her as I rewrote the series, of course, and I added a few things not like me, naturally. But Ella still seeks a reason to smile, always. She still believes in hope, in every situation. And her knack for misplacing things—herself included—might be borrowed (and exaggerated) from my remarkable ability to lose things that I sat down right there two minutes ago.

Ella got new adventures, new goals, new excitement in her life—but she’s still the Ella I got to know all those years ago. And her hero, Cayton, is still the sometimes surly, too-realistic, very different-from-Ella man he has to be to counteract her.

My editor, in her notes to me, said, “Cayton and Ella are so very different. In a way, you wonder how they’ll make it work. And yet you can’t help think they will, and want them to.”

The love story in this book is partly mine, too. Because though on the surface my husband isn’t much like Cayton, in the ways that matters, he is. He’s my opposite, but my perfect complement. He doesn’t always see the bright side I cling to, but he’d never ask me not to cling on anyway. We view the world very differently—and can face it because we’re together.

I love all my books, all my characters. But A Lady Unrivaled . . . well, it’s just so very Ella. I hope you love it just a fraction as much as I do!

Blog Stops

September 22: 100 pages per hour
September 22: Smiling Book Reviews
September 23: Book by Book
September 23: Bibliophile Reviews
September 24: bigreadersite
September 24: Jeanette’s Thoughts
September 25: The Power of Words
September 25: Pause for Tales
September 26: Faithfully Bookish
September 27: Back Porch Reads
September 28: cherylbbookblog
September 28: D’S QUILTS & BOOKS
September 29: Heidi Reads…
September 30: The Scribbler
September 30: Karen’s Krayons
October 3: Colonial Quills


I’m giving away a complete set of the Ladies of the Manor Series PLUS a special surprise straight from England! (US addresses only for paperbacks; an international winner is eligible for digital gifts, though!)