Hello everyone,
Today’s review is on She, Myself and I by Emma Young.
She, Myself and I is a book tha has been on my physical TBR for over three years – ever since I received an ARC at YallWest in 2017 – and I’ve finally had a chance to get to it. Before I get started with my review, I do want to note that this a review for the ARC and not the final version of the book, so there are probably some difference from what I read and the final copy.
She, Myself and I follows Rosa who is a quadraplegic as a resut of a nerve disease which is slowly killing her. However, she has an opportunity to have a new lease on life when a doctor in Boston asks her to take part in an experimental surgery – a brain transplant. Her and her family move form Londno that she can have the surgery.
Everything goes according to plan and Rosa’s brain is successfully transplanted into the body of brain-dead Sylvia Johnson. While Rosa starts to recover from her surgery, she struggles to find her identity – is she Rosa or Sylvia? Who is she really? Matters are not helped when she overhears a nurse praying over her for her death because she believes that the brain transplant was evil. This incident haunts Rosa and causes her to question herself and her existence even more. The one day she meets Joe, and intern for Bostonstream, who writes stories about the people he meets in the park outside the hosputal. With his help, Rosa sets out on a journey to find out who Sy;via was in order to find herself – she ultimately disocvers that it is up herself to decide who she is moving forward as Rosa.
I liked this book – however it lagged in places and seemed a little bit jarring at times. I liked following Rosa on her journey to discovering herself and her self-worth. I did enjoy the allusions to Frankenstein in this book and how Rosa in some ways views herself as a type of Frankenstein’s monster because of the brain transplant.
I also enjoyed getting to know Joe and how he treats Rosa and respects her privacy, even though he is a journalist. I like how he cares about upholding integrity and not making advances in his career.
Another character I really liked was Rosa’s brother Elliott. Even though he was a typical brother, he also provides some wise advice to Rosa, which ultimately helps her come to terms with her identity.
While I liked the novel, it was hard to get into and it just seemed very open-ended, which I think was the point. 3/5 Stars.
Happy Reading,
Janelle L. C.